laze.net
May 13, 2004
My take on MT3

Movable Type 3.0 is available.

I've gotta say that while the new features are intriguing, I'm not very psyched about their new licensing options, even with Mena's reasonable explanation. As a long-time supporter of Movable Type, what I've appreciated most is how Ben and Mena were very close with their users. I remember sending Ben an e-mail about Movable Type a few years back, asking him whether he thought it would be a good answer for the UA Journal. I got a personal response. A few months ago, I wrote to Six Apart to ask a simple question about corporate licensing and never got a response. Things have changed.

And to a point, I understand. Six Apart exists to make money, to spread blogging into the corporate environment, and to support personal publishing, probably in that order. But I can't help but feel that they've really gotten it wrong with their new licensing scheme. Perhaps it's because as it is now, I'm using a registered version of MT (that means I voluntarily donated back in the day) to maintain a total of 11 different blogs. I can do so freely, set up more copies, and publish to as many other blogs as I wish. Under the new pricing structure, there's not even a pricing structure that would support me. The closest (which supports ten blogs) is $150. $150. That's a lot of money.

There's been a lot of negative feedback thusfar about the pricing scheme and people discussing jumping ship to other blogging tools. Wordpress or Text Pattern, perhaps? It should be noted that a free, unsupported of Movable Type will continue to exist, with a one author, three blog limitation (is that per-installation, I wonder?).

I'm really not sure about what the future of Movable Type and Six Apart is. I'm pretty crappy when it comes to business-related issues (if you saw the tax return for my LLC, you'd agree). All I know is that this marks the official shift away from the cozy little company of two that birthed Movable Type and toward more standard business-centric (versus user-centric) practices. I wish them the best of luck, especially Ben and Mena because they're both such nice people, but I definitely don't see myself upgrading to MT 3.0.

11:17 AM


Comments

And Mena's own description of how credits for previous donations/licenses will work does not at all match what the MT store site says. The store says "$20 for the first key, $25 for your second key, and $20 for any subsequent keys" while Mena says the full amount of previous money given to MT will count as a credit.

Well, which is it?

Posted by: The One True b!X on May 13, 2004 12:20 PM

Interesting. When I read the $20/$25/$20 quote today, I thought I rememebered them always saying that the full donation would go towards the upgrade price.

I'd be willing to bet that they change it in our favor (full donation). To go against what had been promised before would be an evil thing to do and Six Apart is still far from evil.

Posted by: Ryan on May 13, 2004 12:26 PM

I've been a big fan of SA too, but I think this is a classic example of why open source is good. If MT was open source, they wouldn't be able to change the game like this. Well, they could, but somebody else could modify the source and offer a competing free version.

I've successfully installed Blosxom in the past, and I like the simplicity of it. I may go that direction if I decide to change.

Posted by: Chris on May 13, 2004 12:35 PM

To answer your question about the limits being per installation--I believe the license only allows one installation.

I'm happy to pay, as I have in the past, but I need a tool I can use. The current limitations on personal use leave me no choice but to look for something else.

I'll wait, as I'd be surprised if changes didn't come. In fact, if changes don't come after the tremendous outcry, that's a good reason to walk away in itself.

Posted by: Cat on May 14, 2004 9:57 AM

Hmm...I feel like such a blog nomad, and I don't like it. But damn, that's way too much $$ for me. :o/

Posted by: JeanNINE on May 18, 2004 2:02 PM


Post a comment

Name: (required)

E-mail Address: (required, not published)

URL:

Comments:


Remember info?

You are reading...

... an inidividual entry on twist of fait accomplis, the Official, Authorized, Sanctioned, and Supported Blog of Laze.Net. You might want to go to the front page for more recent goodness or browse through the archives below. Maury loves you.

Archives

Monthly Archives

Special Archives
Blogathon 2001
Blogathon 2002
Funny, True Stories in One Sentence
31 Days, 31 Horror Movies
Erika Sifrit Posts

Powered by Movable Type